Zirconia tells the Amazon Trio to go after Amy. Tiger's Eye is the one who goes after her. When he does, he recognizes Mina, though she does not recognize him. He invites Amy over to his "private beach", but she turns him down.
Later, Amy and Sammy go out in a raft. Tiger's Eye decides to get Sammy out of the way by knocking him into the water and trying to drown him, but he is saved by Amy, who then performs CPR on him at shore. Tiger's Eye reveals his true identity to Amy, traps her, and extracts her dream mirror. Sailor Moon, Sailor Mini Moon, Sailor Mars, Sailor Jupiter, and Sailor Venus arrive, so Tiger's Eye sends a goofy Remless named Ponko after them.
Ponko attacks the Sailor Scouts with bombs while Tiger's Eye looks into Amy's dream mirror, searching her dreams for Pegasus, but doesn't find him. Tuxedo Mask attacks Ponko, stuffing his hat in her mouth. Sailor Mini Moon summons Pegasus with Crystal Twinkle Bell, and Sailor Moon destroys Ponko with Moon Gorgeous Meditation.
Afterwards, Amy and Sammy watch fireworks on the beach.
- First and last appearance of Remless Ponko
- The title is a play on the 1965 movie Beach Blanket Bingo.