Zirconia chastises the Amazon Trio for their repeated failures (despite the fact that some of the targets who turned out not to be the holder of Pegasus were those that he himself picked out for them). Tiger's Eye decides to go after several girls at once, with several pictures of girls going to a college festival. As he leaves, however, he drops the picture of Lita.
Serena, Amy, Raye, Lita, Mina, and Rini are all attending the festival. When Tiger's Eye arrives, he is unaware that she is one of the targets (as he lost her picture) and asks her to dance. Lita falls in love with Tiger's Eye.
Fish Eye wins a beauty pagent at the festival. When Tiger's Eye asks her why she is there, she says she was here to give her Lita's picture that he lost, and gives it to him. Serena and Rini overhear what they are saying.
Tiger's Eye does not attack Lita, so Fish Eye reveals her true identity and extracts Lita's dream mirror. She traps Amy, Raye, and Mina in a net. Tiger's Eye reveals his true identity and looks into Lita's dream mirror, but does not find Pegasus. Serena and Rini transform into Sailor Moon and Sailor Mini Moon and confront Tiger's Eye and Fish Eye. Tiger's Eye leaves Fish Eye to deal with them and leaves. Fish Eye summons a Remless named Shuffle. Shuffle attacks the Sailor Scouts with cards, until Lita transforms into Sailor Jupiter and hits him with Superior Sparkling Thunder. Sailor Mini Moon uses Crystal Twinkle Bell to call Pegasus, and Sailor Moon destroys Shuffle with Moon Gorgeous Meditation.
Lita says she'll find her prince charming next time.
- First and last appearance of Remless Shuffle
- This is the only time one of the Amazon Trio targets a person, and a different member of the Amazon Trio summons a Remless to fight the Sailor Scouts